Puppy or Adult: Which is Right for You?

Puppy or Adult: Which is Right for You?

By: PetPlace Staff

You have decided to open your heart and your home to a dog. Now you need to decide whether to adopt an adult or a puppy. Each has advantages and disadvantages and the final decision is based on your family's needs and lifestyle.

Advantages of an Adult

Adult dogs are full-grown when they are adopted. You don't have to guess how big the dog will get. The trial-and-error learning phase is already over. The adult dog is usually housebroken and sleeps through the night. He doesn't need so many trips to the vet and has outgrown his impulse to take everything in his mouth and chew on it. An older dog – especially one who has already shared a household or played with other petsStain and Odor Remover
Nature's Miracle Stain and Odor Remover is Guaranteed to remove pet accident stains and odors that other products fail to remove including old uri...
– is more likely to meld into the existing hierarchy established by your other dogs and cats.

Advantages of a Puppy

A puppy is a clean slate. You get to teach him and watch him grow. Puppies are adorable and entertaining.

When adopting a puppy, you get the advantage of developing a strong lifelong bond. A puppy has the potential to be in your family longer than an adult dog.

Disadvantages of an Adult

Some adult dogs are available for adoption due to behavior problems. In an adult dog, some of these negative behaviors can make a difficult pet. You are unsure of the environment the dog came from. The fact that they yelled at him, gave him confusing commands or didn't do a good job of keeping him from tearing up the house might be the reason he ended up in the shelter. Or maybe his previous owners spoiled and pampered him, indulging all his doggy desires. Also, it might take the grown-up dog more time to bond with you.

Disadvantages of a Puppy

Even with the best guess, you are not sure of the puppy's final size and weight. During their early life, puppies can be destructive. Housetraining can be frustrating and training takes time and patience.

After learning about the positive and negative aspects of puppies and adult dogs, step back and take a look at your life. Do you have the time and patience it takes to raise a puppy? If so, you will have a loving pet that you have trained to fit perfectly into your family. If you are willing to adopt an older dog, even with minor flaws, you will have a greatly, devoted companion.

 
Printable Version
 
Have a Pet Question?
Send Your Pet Question to Dr. Jon
and His Staff of Veterinarians Ask Dr. Jon
Dr. Jon's Newsletter
Yes! Send Me the Latest Health Information, Pet Tips, Pet Stories and more...
 
 

Related Articles

  • 1 The Time of Your Life: Do You Have Enough for a Dog?

    It's not hard to see why people compare owning a dog to having children: once you’ve met the health needs of both, the most precious commodity you can give is time. Unfortunately, time is a commodity that...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 2 Want to Get a Dog? Here Are the Best Places to Find Them

    You've decided that a dog is to be your companion, and where to look for one may be as important as what kind of dog you choose. Each possibility has advantages and disadvantages, so investigate several...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 3 Your Guide to the Costs of Pet Ownership

    Before embarking on the lifelong commitment of owning a pet, learn what costs you may incur; this is an important consideration and may even help you decide which pet is best for you and your budget.

    Read MoreRead More
  • 4 Bringing Home an Adult Dog

    Puppies are cute, but you hesitate to bring one home because you know they can gobble up your time and attention; you may be a candidate for a mellow dog, well past puppyhood who can ease into your lifestyle...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 5 Here Comes the Puppy

    Of course you're thrilled about bringing home the new puppy. But before you bring him home, spend some time puppy-proofing the house and gathering the supplies you'll need to start your relationship on...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 6 Guide to Picking the Breed That's Right For You

    Choosing the right dog – the breed, the size, the temperament, the cost – is the key first step to building a healthy and happy relationship with a pet; get it right it's deeply rewarding; get it wrong...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 7 Are You Ready for a Dog?

    Before you adopt, it is very important to consider the impact a new pet will have on your family, as well as the feelings of the animal. There are lots of questions you need to ask, so here's a guide...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 8 Picking the Perfect Puppy

    Bringing a dog into your life is a big step, but although they’re fun, puppies can also be a handful. Before you even venture near the local animal shelter, make sure you’re really ready to undertake the...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 9 Fetching the Top Dog for Your Life

    You brought a pooch into your home in order to teach your children responsibility, but you’re the only one who learned the lesson: Never do anything like that again. Bringing a dog into your home is a...

    Read MoreRead More
Related Articles
  • 1Are You Ready for a Dog?

    Before you adopt, it is very important to consider the impact a new pet will have on your family, as well as the feelings of the animal. There are lots of questions you need to ask, so here's a guide...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 2Bringing Home an Adult Dog

    Puppies are cute, but you hesitate to bring one home because you know they can gobble up your time and attention; you may be a candidate for a mellow dog, well past puppyhood who can ease into your lifestyle...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 3Fetching the Top Dog for Your Life

    You brought a pooch into your home in order to teach your children responsibility, but you’re the only one who learned the lesson: Never do anything like that again. Bringing a dog into your home is a...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 4Guide to Picking the Breed That's Right For You

    Choosing the right dog – the breed, the size, the temperament, the cost – is the key first step to building a healthy and happy relationship with a pet; get it right it's deeply rewarding; get it wrong...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 5Here Comes the Puppy

    Of course you're thrilled about bringing home the new puppy. But before you bring him home, spend some time puppy-proofing the house and gathering the supplies you'll need to start your relationship on...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 6Picking the Perfect Puppy

    Bringing a dog into your life is a big step, but although they’re fun, puppies can also be a handful. Before you even venture near the local animal shelter, make sure you’re really ready to undertake the...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 7The Time of Your Life: Do You Have Enough for a Dog?

    It's not hard to see why people compare owning a dog to having children: once you’ve met the health needs of both, the most precious commodity you can give is time. Unfortunately, time is a commodity that...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 8Want to Get a Dog? Here Are the Best Places to Find Them

    You've decided that a dog is to be your companion, and where to look for one may be as important as what kind of dog you choose. Each possibility has advantages and disadvantages, so investigate several...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 9Your Guide to the Costs of Pet Ownership

    Before embarking on the lifelong commitment of owning a pet, learn what costs you may incur; this is an important consideration and may even help you decide which pet is best for you and your budget.

    Read MoreRead More
 

Over 10,000 Veterinarian Approved Articles

Related Articles
  • 1Are You Ready for a Dog?

    Before you adopt, it is very important to consider the impact a new pet will have on your family, as well as the feelings of the animal. There are lots of questions you need to ask, so here's a guide...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 2Bringing Home an Adult Dog

    Puppies are cute, but you hesitate to bring one home because you know they can gobble up your time and attention; you may be a candidate for a mellow dog, well past puppyhood who can ease into your lifestyle...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 3Fetching the Top Dog for Your Life

    You brought a pooch into your home in order to teach your children responsibility, but you’re the only one who learned the lesson: Never do anything like that again. Bringing a dog into your home is a...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 4Guide to Picking the Breed That's Right For You

    Choosing the right dog – the breed, the size, the temperament, the cost – is the key first step to building a healthy and happy relationship with a pet; get it right it's deeply rewarding; get it wrong...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 5Here Comes the Puppy

    Of course you're thrilled about bringing home the new puppy. But before you bring him home, spend some time puppy-proofing the house and gathering the supplies you'll need to start your relationship on...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 6Picking the Perfect Puppy

    Bringing a dog into your life is a big step, but although they’re fun, puppies can also be a handful. Before you even venture near the local animal shelter, make sure you’re really ready to undertake the...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 7The Time of Your Life: Do You Have Enough for a Dog?

    It's not hard to see why people compare owning a dog to having children: once you’ve met the health needs of both, the most precious commodity you can give is time. Unfortunately, time is a commodity that...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 8Want to Get a Dog? Here Are the Best Places to Find Them

    You've decided that a dog is to be your companion, and where to look for one may be as important as what kind of dog you choose. Each possibility has advantages and disadvantages, so investigate several...

    Read MoreRead More
  • 9Your Guide to the Costs of Pet Ownership

    Before embarking on the lifelong commitment of owning a pet, learn what costs you may incur; this is an important consideration and may even help you decide which pet is best for you and your budget.

    Read MoreRead More